Questions and answers

How the rankings are built, what we count, and what we keep about you.

How voting works

Why compare two versions instead of rating each one?

Picking between two things is easier and more consistent than giving a score out of ten. You hear two versions of the same song, choose the one you like more, and each choice nudges both versions' scores. After enough choices from enough people, the better-loved versions rise to the top.

How are the scores calculated?

We use an Elo rating, the same idea chess uses. Every version starts at 1,500. When a version wins, it gains points and the other version loses the same amount. Beating a version with a higher score earns more than beating one with a lower score.

Scores move more for versions with few votes and settle as votes pile up. Votes from visitors without an account count a little less (70%) than votes from signed-in accounts.

Can I compare a version of one song with a different song?

No. Versions only compete against other versions of the same song, so a score means something within a song but not across songs. A Tweezer with a high score is not "better" than a Reba with a lower one.

How are pairs chosen?

We favor versions that have few votes so far, then versions with similar scores, since close matchups teach the ranking the most. You will not be shown the same pair twice. Skip records nothing and moves on to a different pair.

What is shuffle?

Turn on Shuffle songs (on the home page or the voting screen) and every vote moves you to a different song. Songs are picked at random, but ones with few votes so far come up more often, so thin rankings fill in faster. Each vote still compares two versions of the same song, so shuffling changes nothing about how scores work. Skip takes you to another song, and switching shuffle off keeps you on the current one.

What is a dream setlist?

A playlist split into Set 1, Set 2, and an encore. Make one from Playlists, or let the generator build a random show: songs land in the set Phish usually plays them in, most of the time, and sets run about as long as real ones. Best of picks from each song's top-ranked versions (the #1, or any of the top 5 or 10); Anything goes picks any version. Lock the songs you like, reroll the rest, then save it and drag songs between sets.

What do Ranked, Early, No votes yet, and Only recording mean?

They tell you how settled a song's ranking is, going by votes. No votes yet: nobody has compared its versions. Early: it has some votes, but not many for the number of versions, so the order can still change a lot. Ranked: at least three votes per version, so each version has been in about six comparisons and the top of the list is fairly settled. A song with a single recording is Only recording; there is nothing to compare it to, so it never enters voting.

What do the confidence labels on a ranking mean?

They reflect how many votes a version has: low under 5, medium under 15, and high from 15 on. A version near the top with low confidence could still move a lot.

How does the preview player decide where to start?

Previews are 30 seconds. If Phish.in marks where the jam starts, the preview begins 5 seconds before it. Otherwise, longer tracks (7 minutes or more) start about a third of the way in, and shorter ones start at the beginning. Press Keep listening to hear the rest. Only one version plays at a time.

Is there a limit on how many votes I can cast?

Yes, though most people will never reach it: about 20 votes a minute, 300 an hour, and 1,000 a day per voter. Anonymous votes are also limited per internet connection, because clearing cookies would otherwise make a fresh voter every time. If several people vote from the same connection, say on shared wifi, signing in gives each of you your own limit. The limits keep a script from flooding a song's ranking.

What is my personal ranking?

While you vote, you'll see a ranking built only from your own picks. If you track the shows you attended, the song page can also limit its ranking to those shows, and it marks versions from shows you attended with a Fishman donut.

Versions and medleys

What counts as a version?

One performance of a song at one show, with a recording available on Phish.in. Songs with no recordings are left out of the lists, and a performance without a recording can't be voted on until one turns up.

Why can't I vote on some performances inside a medley?

Phish.in sometimes packs several songs into a single track when they flow into each other. When that happens, the main song of the medley can still be voted on. Songs that act as bookends around other songs, such as Hold Your Head Up, Alumni Blues, The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday, and Big Ball Jam, stay listenable there but aren't votable, because the track is really about what they surround.

A shared medley track has one length and one jam marker for the whole thing, so we don't show a length for the songs inside it.

How up to date are setlists and recordings?

Setlists come from Phish.net and recordings from Phish.in. For now we refresh from both by hand, so a recent show can take a little while to appear.

Games

What games are there?

Two, each on its own page under Games: Guess the Opener and Encore, played show by show, and Phish Bingo, played over a run of shows with friends. You need an account with a handle to play. Scores come from Phish.net's setlists, so they update the morning after each show, once we pick up the setlist.

How does Guess the Opener and Encore work?

Before each upcoming show, pick the song you think opens set 1 and one you think shows up in the encore. You get a point if your opener pick is the first song of set 1, and a point if your encore pick is played anywhere in the encore, including a second encore. Change your picks as often as you like until noon Pacific on show day. The leaderboard ranks by points; ties go to whoever made fewer picks.

How does Phish Bingo work?

Fill a 5 by 5 card with 24 songs you think they'll play over a run of shows; the center is free and no song can appear twice. A square marks itself when its song is on any setlist in the run. Teases don't count, only songs on the setlist. Whoever marks the most squares by the end of the run wins, and complete rows, columns, and diagonals break ties.

How do I start or join a bingo game?

Give the game a name, choose its first and last show (up to 31 days apart), and share the invite link it gives you. Anyone signed in who opens the link can join, up to 50 players. You have one card per run, so if you're in several games for the same shows, the same card plays in all of them.

When do cards lock?

At noon Pacific on the day of the run's first show. Until then you can change any square, and other players' cards stay hidden so nobody can copy them. After the lock, everyone in the game can see every card.

Can I mark squares myself?

Yes, for the odd cases a setlist doesn't settle. Tap a square on your card to mark it. It shows as waiting until the setlist confirms it or the game's creator accepts it. The creator can also mark, accept, or clear any square on a card in their game, and those marks count right away. Hand marks count in your games only, not in the site-wide standings.

What does “one song per medley” mean in bingo?

Some songs nearly always come together as a medley, so putting two of them on a card is close to a free square. A game started with this rule counts only one song from each medley below; any others on the card stay unmarked. If you play in a game with the rule, your card won't take a second song from the same medley. The site-wide standings always count one per medley, so everyone plays by the same rule there.
  • Mike's Song, I Am Hydrogen, Weekapaug Groove
  • The Horse, Silent in the Morning
  • The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday, Avenu Malkenu
  • Tweezer, Tweezer Reprise
  • Swept Away, Steep
  • Colonel Forbin's Ascent, Fly Famous Mockingbird
  • Alumni Blues, Letter to Jimmy Page
  • Rhombus Narration, Divided Sky

What are the site-wide standings?

Every card for a run, whether or not its owner is in a game, ranked against each other. Only squares the setlists confirm count there, and only one song per medley. Runs stay listed for a week after they end.

Can I print my card?

Yes. A game's page links to a printable copy of your card, and after the lock to every card in the game, one per page with just the song titles, for marking with a pen at the show.

Can I leave, rename, or delete a game?

Any player can leave except the person who started the game. That person can rename or delete it from the bottom of its page. Deleting removes the game and its invite link, but everyone keeps their card, which still counts in the site-wide standings and any other game for that run. Marks the creator made or accepted on other players' cards are cleared.

Tags

What are tags?

Short labels on a version, added by listeners. They show on song rankings, on show setlists, and while you vote, and you can filter a song's ranking by tag, for example only the versions tagged Page.

What do the band-member tags mean?

Trey, Page, Mike, and Fish mean that member really shines in that version: a standout solo, a lead moment, something worth listening for. The other starter tags are Type II jam (the jam leaves the song's structure), Segue (flows straight into the next song), Bustout (the song returns after a long time away) and Tease (quotes or hints at another song).

How do tags get added?

Anyone signed in with a chosen name can add a tag to a version, either one from the list or a new one they propose. Adding a tag someone else already added counts as agreeing with it, and you can take your tag back at any time.

A tag shows to everyone once two people have added it to that version. Until then it's a suggestion, visible to signed-in listeners who can agree with it. You can propose up to 10 new tags a day.

Moderators also add tags to the list everyone picks from, and can move a good proposal onto that list.

What if a tag is wrong or offensive?

Open the tag editor on that version and press the flag next to the tag to report it, with a reason and an optional note. A small group of moderators and admins reviews reports. They can keep a tag, remove it from that version, rename it, merge it into another tag that means the same thing, or delete it. Moderator actions are logged.

Eras and badges

What are the eras?

Fans split the band's history into eras separated by their long breaks. We follow the common convention:

  • 1.0, 1983 to 2000: from the beginning until the hiatus announced in the fall of 2000.
  • 2.0, 2002 to 2004: from the return on New Year's Eve 2002 at Madison Square Garden to the breakup that ended with Coventry in August 2004.
  • 3.0, 2009 to 2020: from the reunion at Hampton Coliseum in March 2009 until touring stopped in the pandemic year of 2020.
  • 4.0, 2021 to today: from the return to the road in 2021.

Fans draw these lines a little differently, so treat them as a convention, not a rule.

How is my era badge decided?

Your badge comes from the first show you've marked as attended. If it falls in 3.0, you're a "3.0er." A show during a break between eras counts toward the era before it.

Is my show count checked?

No. Your show list is what you tell us, whether you check off shows yourself or import them from your Phish.net account. We take your word for it.

Who can see my shows and badges?

Your list of shows is private. Your show count and era badge can appear next to your handle, and you can turn either one off on the Edit profile page.

Can I use my own picture as my avatar?

Yes. On Edit profile, choose Upload a picture, then drag and zoom until it fills the circle. Your browser cuts out just that circle and sends a small copy; the original photo never leaves your device. You can switch back to one of our avatars, or your initial, at any time, and your picture is deleted when you do.

Before a picture is used, a program running on our own server checks that it isn't explicit, and refuses it if it looks like it might be. No check is perfect, so anyone signed in can report a picture from a profile page, and moderators can remove it. You can upload up to ten pictures a day.

What's on my profile?

Your handle links to your profile at /u/your-handle. It shows your avatar, when you joined, your badges (if they're on), how many votes you've cast and tags you've added, your opener and encore points, your best bingo card, and any shared playlists you've chosen to show there. It never shows which versions you voted for, your saved versions, or your list of shows. Turn the whole profile off on the Edit profile page, and people see only your handle and avatar.

On your phone

Can I install it like an app?

Yes. Installed, it gets its own icon on your home screen and opens in its own window, without the browser's address bar. There's nothing to download from an app store, and it's the same site, so your account and votes are all there.

  • iPhone or iPad (Safari): tap the Share button, then Add to Home Screen.
  • Android (Chrome): open the ⋮ menu and choose Install app or Add to Home screen.
  • Computer (Chrome or Edge): click the install icon at the right end of the address bar.

It still needs an internet connection, since recordings stream from Phish.in.

How do I sign in on the installed app?

Use the 6-digit code. Tapping the link in the email opens your regular browser, not the installed app, so you'd end up signed in there instead. Typing the code into the app's sign-in page signs the app in.

Can I control playback from the lock screen?

Yes. While a preview, a full version, or a playlist is playing, your lock screen, notification shade, headphones, or car show the song and show and can pause and resume it. Playlists also get next and previous buttons, and full versions can be scrubbed. If you press play on a preview that has faded out, it carries on as the full version. Whether audio keeps going with the screen off depends on your phone and browser.

Your data

The short answers are below. The full details, including how long things are kept and who else sees them, are in the privacy policy.

How does signing in work, and how long do I stay signed in?

There are no passwords. Enter your email and we send a link and a 6-digit code: tap the link, or type the code on the sign-in page. Either works once and expires in 15 minutes. You then stay signed in on that browser for a year after your last visit, or until you sign out. Downloading your data or deleting your account asks you to sign in again first, and “Sign out everywhere” on your account page ends every session at once, handy after using a shared computer.

What do you keep if I don't sign in?

The first time you vote, we set a cookie holding a random ID, so we can avoid repeating pairs and show your own picks. It lasts a year and contains nothing about you. Your votes are stored with that ID. If you sign in later, those votes move onto your account and the cookie is removed.

Choosing a color theme sets a second cookie that remembers it (and in CK5 mode, a third holding which color scheme is on screen). Your player volume and the Shuffle songs switch are remembered by your browser alone and never sent to us.

To limit vote spam, we count anonymous votes per internet connection. We never store your IP address for this, only a scrambled code made from it that can't be turned back into the address, and the counts are deleted within about two days.

What do you keep if I have an account?

  • Your email address, used to send sign-in links and codes. Beyond those, we'd only email you about a security problem with your data or a significant change to the privacy policy. Anything else would be something you turn on yourself.
  • Google details, if you sign in with Google: your name, email, and profile picture link, plus sign-in tokens from Google. We store them with your account but never show them, and we don't use the tokens to read anything from your Google account.
  • Your handle, the only name anyone else will ever see, and your chosen avatar. If you upload a picture, we keep only a small copy of the part you cropped, never the original photo.
  • Your votes, so rankings and your personal ranking can be rebuilt.
  • Saved versions and playlists. They're private. If you turn on sharing for a playlist, anyone with its link can see the playlist and your handle, nothing else.
  • Tags you add, any tag names you propose, and any reports you send about tags or pictures. Moderators see a report's reason and note, not who sent it. Other people see how many listeners added a tag, not who.
  • Shows you attended, with your show count, first show date, and badge settings.
  • Upcoming shows you're going to. Others only see how many people are going, never who.
  • Your game picks and bingo cards. Your handle and score appear on the leaderboards, and players in your bingo games see your card once the run starts.
  • Your Phish.net username, only if you import shows, kept privately to fill in the form next time.
  • Sign-in sessions, which record when you signed in, your IP address, and your browser type. This is standard for keeping you signed in.
  • Your color theme, so it follows you to other browsers.
  • Tips, if you tip through Ko-fi: the date, amount, and whether you have the Miracle Maker badge. Ko-fi handles the payment, so we never see your card or PayPal details, and we don't keep your tip's message.
  • Your role if you're a moderator, and a suspension with its reason if an admin ever suspends your account.

What can the people who run the site see and do?

A few administrators look after the site. On an account's admin page they can see its email address (so they can match a support request to an account), how it signs in, when it joined and was last active, and counts of its votes, tags, reports, saved versions, playlists, and shows. They don't see which versions you voted for, your session IP addresses, or your list of shows.

They can rename a handle that's offensive or pretends to be someone else, reset an avatar, make someone a moderator, suspend an account, or delete one the same way you would. A suspended account can't vote, tag, report, choose a handle, or share playlists, and its shared links stop working, but you can still download your data (the reason is included) and delete your account. Every admin action is logged.

Do you use ads or tracking?

No. There are no ads, no analytics services, and no third-party tracking scripts. The one outside service your browser talks to is Phish.in: when you press play on a preview, the audio streams straight from Phish.in, so their server sees that request. Nothing downloads from Phish.in until you press play.

Can I download my data?

Yes. On Account and data, Download my data gives you a file with everything listed above that belongs to your account: account details, sign-in sessions, votes, tags, saved versions, playlists, and shows. Sign-in secrets, the keys that keep you signed in, are left out.

Can I delete my account?

Yes, on Account and data. Deleting is permanent. It removes your account, with its email address, sign-in sessions, and Google details; your handle, avatar, and badges; your shows, saved versions, and playlists (shared links stop working); the tags you added; and tag names you proposed that nobody else uses.

Your past votes stay in the community rankings, with no link to you or to any account, so rankings don't shift when someone leaves.

Credits

Where does the information come from?

Setlist and show data is courtesy of Phish.net and The Mockingbird Foundation, used under their terms for non-commercial projects.

Recordings are courtesy of Phish.in. We store links to their tracks, never the audio itself.

Who runs this site?

Theme from the Top is built and run by Curt Hutton (@multibeast), a longtime fan. It's an independent fan project, not affiliated with Phish, Phish.net, or Phish.in. How the site handles your data is in the privacy policy.

What's the raised finger at the bottom of the page?

The site's tip jar. Outside a sold-out show, fans hoping for a free ticket hold up one finger: they're looking for a miracle. This site is free with no ads, and the finger is it asking, quietly, for help with hosting costs. It leads to the miracle page, where you can tip through Ko-fi with a card or PayPal, no Ko-fi account needed.

Tip with the same email as your account here, or put your @handle in the tip's message, and you get the Miracle Maker badge, and the finger turns into a peace sign. Tipping for a friend? Put their @handle in the message instead. You can hide the badge on Edit profile. Tipping never unlocks anything; the whole site is the same for everyone.

What's CK5 mode?

A tribute to Chris Kuroda, Phish's longtime lighting designer, who fans call CK5: the fifth member of the band. Pick CK5 in the theme switch at the top of the page and the site repaints itself in a new set of colors on every page, the way his rig changes the room from song to song. Press it again for a new look on the page you're on. On the home page, beams sweep behind the headline, and when you vote, a spotlight lands on your pick.

The colors only fade from one look to the next; nothing flashes or strobes. If your device asks for reduced motion, the colors change without fading and the beams hold still. The color schemes are our own, in the spirit of his work, and the site isn't affiliated with him or the band.

Is this an official Phish site?

No. This is an unofficial fan project and isn't affiliated with Phish, Phish.net, or Phish.in.